Animal performance
The mean, minimum, and maximum values of AT, RH, and THI for a total of 16 weeks from the 1st to 4th period of this experiment were all different by periods (p<0.05). The average AT, RH, and THI of the 1st period, which was the highest heat stress period during the whole experiment, were 32.8°C, 74.1%, and 87.0, respectively. These values showed a heat stress condition in the severe (THI 85 to 99) stage according to THI chart of NIAS (2022) [
6] for fattening Hanwoo steers. The average values of the 2nd period were 27.5°C, 76.5%, and 82.8, respectively, indicating a moderate (THI 82 to 84) stage. The average AT of the 2nd period was lower than that of the 1st period (p<0.05), but the RH was higher (p<0.05). After the hot season, the average AT, RH, and THI of the 3rd period decreased to 25.1°C, 72.3%, and 71.4, respectively, and, in the 4th period, to 21.3°C, 56.5%, and 68.1, respectively. Both of these periods were regarded under the comfort (THI 75 or less) condition according to THI chart of NIAS (2022) [
6] (
Table 3).
The BW, DMI, average daily gain (ADG), and FCR of animals measured at initial and every 4 weeks during the experiment are presented in
Table 5. The initial BW of control, PF, PF+GL, and PF+GL+SBM were 738.6, 712.9, 729.1, and 718.2 kg, respectively, with no significant differences among treatments. The final BW of Control, PF, PF+GL, and PF+GL+SBM were 814.4, 803.6, 828.4, and 812.7 kg, respectively, with no significant differences among treatments.
Prior to the
in vivo experiment, a palatability trial was conducted using the experimental TMR diets of control, PF, PF+GL, and PF+GL+SBM as a preliminary test. Eight early-fattening and five late-fattening Hanwoo steers were placed in four pens. The four experimental diets were fed twice a day for 1 h at 0900 and 1700, and the residuals were measured. The locations of the four diets were randomized at every 5 days for a total of 15 days, and animals were provided sufficient amounts of feeds to prevent consuming feeds from other treatments due to lack of feeds [
19]. The mean DMI of control, PF, PF+GL, and PF+GL+SBM were 1.56, 2.90, 3.83, and 3.98 kg/h, respectively, indicating that the diets of PF, PF+GL, and PF+GL+SBM were more palatable than control (p<0.05). Consequently, added protected fat and glycerol can be assumed to have a positive effect on palatability for Hanwoo steer.
The DMI was not significantly different among all treatments during the whole experiment period, even though feeds were offered
ad libitum for the late-fattening period. According to NRC (2016) [
9], feed intake decreases when feeding diets with higher energy levels. In this study, the energy level was increased by 10% in PF and PF+GL, and both energy and protein levels were increased by 10% in PF+GL+ SBM compared to Control, but no decrease in DMI was observed. In the 1st period with relatively high THI, the DMI of control, PF, PF+GL, and PF+GL+SBM was measured at 7.00, 6.98, 7.01, and 6.94 kg, respectively. This indicates an approximately 33% decrease in DMI compared to the daily TMR feeding amount of 10.5 kg/d (DM basis; assuming an as-fed 15 kg/d including 30% moisture) recommended for late-fattening Hanwoo steers in NIAS (2017) [
12]. In addition, compared to the 4th period, which entered the comfort stage after passing the high stress period, DMI in the 1st period decreased by about 30%. It is worth noting that the average THI of the 1st period was 87.0, which is a relatively low level of heat stress for a severe (THI 85 to 99) condition, but the decrease in DMI was very significant. The DMI in the 2nd period was 8.25, 7.80, 8.30, and 8.28 kg/d for control, PF, PF+GL, and PF+GL+SBM, respectively, which is approximately 18% less than the 4th period. Entering the 3rd period following the heat stress period in September, the DMI was 9.64, 9.32, 9.55, and 9.53 kg/d, and DMI in the 4th period was 9.94, 10.00, 10.01, and 10.01 kg/d, respectively. The decrease in DMI of ruminants under heat stress environments results in physiological changes due to excessive heat accumulation in the body [
2,
20]. Reduced DMI can cause serious economic losses through reduced productivity because the animals eating less would be unable to fulfill their nutrient requirements. In addition, ruminants have a physiologic response to high THI by increasing heat dissipation through increased peripheral blood volume and respiratory rate, resulting in an increase in metabolic rate as body temperature increases [
6]. Under these circumstances, the energy requirements for maintenance may increase to 110% [
6], and the use of energy feeds should be considered both to meet increased energy requirement and to compensate for the decrease in DMI [
21].
In the 1st period, the ADG of control, PF, PF+GL, and PF+GL+SBM were 0.45, 0.74, 0.71, and 0.65 kg/d, respectively, showing higher values of treatment groups compared to control (p<0.05). In the 2nd period, the ADG of PF (0.85), PF+GL (0.86), and PF+GL+SBM (0.92) were higher than that of Control (0.67 kg/d) (p<0.05). Considering the 1st and 2nd period of the THI stages of fattening Hanwoo steers suggested by NIAS (2022) [
6] were severe (85 to 99) and moderate (THI 82 to 84), respectively, ADG during these periods were significantly improved in all treatments fed 10% additional energy alone or energy and protein levels. In the 3rd period of post-hot season, ADG tended to improve only numerically in all treatments compared to control. On the other hand, there were no significant differences in ADG among treatments in the 4th period. The reason for this is unclear, but it is possible that the BW gain effect was not fully expressed during the late-fattening period just before transporting to a slaughterhouse. Furthermore, as the animal’s BW approaches 800 kg, the energy utilization rate gradually decreases, it is likely that the extra energy may not be expressed in BW [
6]. The ADG of Control, PF, PF+GL, and PF+GL+SBM in the whole period (16 weeks) was 0.65, 0.79, 0.85, and 0.83 kg/d, respectively, which was higher in all treatments compared to Control primarily due to the high difference during the 1st and 2nd period (p<0.05).
According to NIAS (2017) [
12], the EE contents in beef cattle diets should be 2% to 5% of the total DMI. In this experiment, the EE of the control diet was 5.35%, which was up to the limit (
Table 2). However, in treatment groups that increased energy or energy and protein levels, EE contents in the diets exceeded 10%. Although 5% EE is generally recommended as an upper limit, additional feeding in the form of protected fat is acceptable because it does not affect rumen fermentation. It is also common practice in the dairy industry to feed up to 3% protected fat as a top dressing during the heat stress season [
22].
Glycerol can partially replace corn and the inclusion of up to 15% in the diet of late-fattening steers does not affect productivity and carcass characteristics [
23]. However, in this study, it was not possible to increase the energy level up to 10% by using glycerol alone when formulating a ratio based on NIAS (2017) [
12]. No differences were observed in DMI and ADG due to the presence of glycerol addition, i.e. PF vs PF+GL. Meanwhile, when comparing the economic feasibility of glycerol with a protected fat, glycerol is not recommended as a good source of energy for the diet of heat stress.
When PF+GL+SBM increased protein levels by 10% was compared to PF+GL, there was no clear advantage in ADG of late-fattening Hanwoo steers. This may be a result of the additional energy required to convert excess ammonia to urea by increasing CP levels without considering rumen-protected protein [
6]. On the other hand, Kim et al [
15] conducted experiments on Hanwoo calves under mild (THI 71 to 74), moderate (THI 81 to 83), and severe (THI 89 to 91) conditions by fixing the energy level in the diet of 72% to 74% TDN and varying the CP level to 12.5%, 15.0%, and 17.5%. The results showed that feeding 17.5% CP under severe improved ADG by about 61%, compared to feeding 12.5%. However, Hanwoo steers in this study were at a stage of late fattening when energy level is relatively more important than CP for maintenance and marbling. Thus, additional feeding of soybean meal may not have a clear effect on productivity in this experiment.
The FCR of the 1st and 2nd period was improved in all treatments compared to control (p<0.05). The FCR during the 3rd and 4th period did not show significant differences among treatment groups. However, in the whole experimental period, FCR was significantly lower in all treatments (p< 0.05) compared to control (13.50). Similar to the ADG results, there was no significant difference between increased energy level treatments (PF and PF+GL) and PF+GL+SBM. Therefore, the results of this study suggest that feeding TMR diets with 110% increased energy level has a positive effect on mitigating productivity decline due to heat stress in late-fattening Hanwoo steers. However, the effect of increasing the protein level by 10% was not clear, so further experiments considering the level of rumen-protected protein will be necessary.
Physiological parameters
The RT results of late-fattening Hanwoo steers fed diets with a 10% increase in energy and protein contents using protected fat, glycerol, and soybean meal under heat stress are shown in
Table 6 and
Figure 1. The RT is the most common method of measuring body temperature in livestock, and an increase in RT of ruminants indicates increased metabolic heat production in the body [
24]. In this study, RT was not significantly different among treatments during the whole experimental period. However, when compared by periods, the mean RT was higher in the following order: 4th (10/28; 38.48°C), 3rd (9/30; 38.43°C), 2nd (9/2; 38.75°C), 1st (8/5; 38.81°C), and 0 period (7/9; 38.84°C) (p<0.05). Both the 0 and 1st period at Severe stage and the 2nd period at Moderate stage were higher values compared to the 3rd and 4th period of comfort (p<0.05;
Figure 1). Thus, it was confirmed that the animals were already experiencing heat stress from the 0 period. The previous study [
25] that measured the RT of early-fattening Hanwoo steers in chambers with precisely controlled AT and RH showed that it was 37.39°C, 37.80°C, 38.65°C, and 39.20°C in comfort (THI 73 to 75), mild (THI 77 to 79), moderate (THI 82 to 84), and severe (THI 85 to 86), respectively (p<0.05), and the difference between severe and comfort was approximately 1.8°C. The NIAS (2022) [
6] reported that the RT of fattening steers was 39.3 for severe, 38.9 to 39.2 for moderate, and 38.5°C to 38.8°C for mild. The results from this study were lower than those of Woo et al [
25] and NIAS (2022) [
6]. The reason is probably that this study was conducted in an outdoor environment and the animals had time to recover from the heat stress by natural wind and at night when the THI was relatively lower. Although RT in ruminants is known to be positively correlated with THI (R
2 = 0.62) [
26], the significant decrease in the DMI of the 1st and 2nd period compared to the 3rd and 4th period indicated that this experiment was conducted under sufficient heat stress conditions.
Serum cortisol in this study was not significant among treatments during the whole experimental period (
Table 6;
Figure 2). However, when comparing between periods, the mean serum cortisol concentrations were 8.63 (0 period), 8.59 (1st), 8.89 (2nd), 8.02 (3rd), and 6.19 ng/mL (4th). The serum cortisol concentrations in 0, 1st (severe), and 2nd period (moderate) were the highest, 3rd period was higher than 4th period at the comfort level (p<0.05;
Figure 2). In the experiment using a climatic controlled chamber, serum cortisol levels in early-fattening Hanwoo steers were higher in the order of severe (17.17), moderate (15.57), mild (13.51), and comfort (11.98 ng/mL) phases [
25]. In another study [
27] on Hanwoo steers in an external environment, increased blood cortisol levels were observed after exposure to THI 80 to 87 (9.87) compared to THI 64 to 71 (1.91) and THI 72 to 79 (5.13 ng/mL). The concentration of cortisol, a hormone secreted from the adrenal cortex, increases under heat stress conditions [
28]. There is a positive correlation (R
2 = 0.59) between cortisol and THI [
26]. Based on the results of this study and other studies, the NIAS (2022) [
6] reported that blood cortisol levels of 1 to 4, 5 to 6, and 6 ng/mL or more in mild, moderate, and severe, respectively, but these values are considered too low. In addition, cortisol concentrations in the 0 and 1st period of this study were higher than those of the 3rd and 4th period, indicating that animals experienced high levels of heat stress during the 1st period.
The blood parameters of animals measured at the beginning of the experiment and every 4 weeks are presented in
Table 6. Concentrations of serum glucose showed no significant differences among treatments. However, the glucose concentrations in 0 and 1st period were the lowest, and 3rd period was lower than 4th period (p<0.05). Serum glucose is the primary energy source utilized by ruminants during heat stress [
29]. Glycerol is mainly converted to propionic acid by rumen microorganisms and enters the glucogenic pathway to temporarily increase blood glucose, which can be directly used as an energy source [
30]. Thus, higher glucose level indicates that glycerol in PF+GL and PF+GL+SBM contributes to energy supply during heat stress. Protected fat may not have a direct effect on blood glucose levels because they do not interfere with rumen fermentation and can be absorbed in the small intestine to provide more energy for ruminants [
31]. When used in combination with glycerol, protected fat can be used for energy storage while glycerol may act as an energy source. Several studies [
7,
26] have reported a decrease in blood glucose due to heat stress. Firstly, this is because energy requirements for homeostasis control increase due to an increase in body temperature under heat stress, while energy intake decreases, and blood glucose is rapidly consumed. Secondly, the endocrine system may be affected under heat stress conditions, having a negative effect on the process of gluconeogenesis [
32]. In this study, the serum glucose concentration of late-fattening Hanwoo steers tended to decrease in the 0, 1st, and 2nd period of heat stress compared to the 3rd and 4th period of following heat stress.
Concentrations of blood TG and TCHO were not significantly different among treatments during the entire experiment. The TG concentration showed an interaction of treatment and time (p<0.05) with a relatively low treatment effect. The TCHO concentration in 0 period at Severe was higher than that of other periods (p<0.05). Another study reported that the TCHO and TG concentrations tend to increase with higher energy intake and better growth performance in ruminants [
33]. Kang et al [
7] reported that supplemental feeding of protected fat to Hanwoo steers did not affect blood TG and TCHO concentrations compared to control. Therefore, the relationship between increased energy and protein levels and blood TG and TCHO concentrations during heat stress is considered unclear.
Blood NEFA showed no significant differences among treatments during whole period. The NEFA concentration was a low time effect, suggesting an interaction between treatment and time. This is due to the fact that blood NEFA increases by breaking down the fat stored in the body and releasing it into the blood to supplement the required energy because the energy intake is insufficient due to heat stress [
34]. In contrast, treatments that increased energy and (or) protein levels appear to have lower blood NEFA levels because sufficient energy and protein were supplied.
Blood BUN concentrations showed no significant differences among treatments in the whole period. However, the mean BUN concentrations of 0, 1st, and 2nd period were higher than those of 3rd and 4th period (p<0.05). The mechanisms of the increase in BUN were unclear, but first, it may be attributed to the increased production of rumen ammonia or proteolysis of skeletal muscle [
35]. Second, heat-stressed ruminants have increased BUN levels compared to thermoneutral control, suggesting that rumen ammonia was inefficiently synthesized into microbial CP [
35]. Thus, it was possible that blood ammonia concentrations were increased by surplus rumen ammonia [
36]. Overall, blood parameters that can determine nutritional levels, such as glucose, TG, TCHO, NEFA, and BUN, are not appropriate indicators for determining the degree of heat stress.